How to Make Pulled Pork in a Crock Pot

Jump to Recipe

One of my go-to main dishes to make when I am hosting a get-together has got to be homemade barbecue pulled pork sandwiches. I absolutely love pulled pork. Whether plain and in some yummy tacos or with barbecue sauce in the form of a sandwich, I don’t care. Give me that pork!

This recipe I have been making for over 20 years. It was a staple when I was at college and we wanted to have a bunch of people over but not have it cost a ton. You can’t go wrong with this recipe when it comes to feeding a large group.

If you are a fan of pulled pork give this recipe a try! Let’s get started!

Ingredients and Tools/Equipment

In order to make slow cooker pulled pork you need a handful of ingredients:

• Pork – Traditionally pork shoulder or pork butt is used, but I also like using the pork loin. Honestly, I just buy whatever is on sale, haha. All three will work great.
• Onion – I normally will use a yellow onion, but you can use white or purple/red as well.
• Garlic cloves – Fresh garlic is always awesome with pork.
• Garlic powder – I add this even when adding fresh garlic. I really love garlic with pork.
• Black pepper
• Oregano
• Salt – Always adds flavor
• Paprika – Either regular or smoked.
• Root beer – Or you can use Dr. Pepper or Orange Juice. Each one brings a different flavor element.
• Barbecue Sauce – You can use this homemade barbecue sauce recipe if you like or use something like Sweet Baby Ray’s which is my favorite brand to buy at the store.

Tools/Equipment

• Slow cooker – It doesn’t have to be the Crock Pot brand, any large slow cooker will work just fine.
• Forks
• Tongs
• Bowl
• Ladle
• Knife

How to make pulled pork in Crock Pot

Start by prepping your onion. You can slice them or dice them, it is up to you. I like to do slices just because they are easier to grab with tongs and I like them in my pulled pork sandwich or tacos. But you can just dice them if you prefer.

Also, prepare the cloves of garlic by removing the skins and slicing them in half. No need to smash them or mince them.

Take all the dry ingredients, the paprika, garlic powder, black pepper, oregano, and salt, and add them to a bowl. Mix it well with a fork or whisk.

The dry rub is ready.

Prep the pork

Remove the pork from the wrapper and drain any juices. Then place it on a cutting board and pat it dry with paper towels.

Next, sprinkle about half of the dry rub onto one side of the pork. Rub it in with your hand.

NOTE: You can wear kitchen/food prep gloves if desired. And of course, if you are making it to sell, then you should be wearing gloves, as per proper food handling requirements.

Flip the pork over and apply the rest of the dry rub and pat it on the pork.

This next step is optional, but I always do it. Something I learned 20 years ago. Take a knife and cut deep slits into the pork. Then take your garlic pieces and press those into each of the slits.

Otherwise, you can just place the garlic in the slow cooker.

Cooking the Slow Cooker Pulled Pork

Add the slices of onions (or diced) to the bottom of the slow cooker. Then add the dry-rubbed pork on top of the onions.

Pour the root beer, Dr. Pepper, or orange juice in as well. Each one of those adds a little different flavor profile, but you can’t go wrong with any of them.

Cover the Crock Pot and cook. You have a few cooking options:

1 – Set on high and cook for 4 hours.

2 – Set on high for 2 hours then low for 4 hours.

3 – Set on low and cook for 8 hours.

Making pulled pork is very forgiving with several options for cooking it depending on your schedule.

Shredding the Pork

When the pork is done the internal temp should be between 190F and 210F. (87 to 98C)

If you don’t have a thermometer don’t worry, if you follow the guidelines for cooking the pork it should be ready without checking it with a thermometer. If it shreds easily it is definitely ready.

There will be lots of extra liquid in the pot which will be too much for the pulled pork. You can use a turkey baster and suck up the liquid and then discard or save it for gravy, or make an Au jus with it.

Or what I normally do is remove the pork with tongs from the slow cooker and put it in a large bowl. Then I shred it with two forks.

Next, take your tongs and grab those onions from the slow cooker and put them with the meat. Along with a few ladles of juice. You want to keep some of the juice because it will keep the pulled pork from drying out.

Mix the onions, juice, and pulled pork all together. And then it is ready. You can serve it as is for sandwiches and pork tacos or whatever else you want to use it for or add barbecue sauce to it.

Maybe you want to keep half plain and then add barbecue sauce to the other half, totally up to you.

Serving the Pulled Pork

I like to mix in the barbecue sauce with the pork as opposed to just adding a bit on top of it. But you are welcome to do it however you like.

TIP: If you are waiting for a bunch of people to come over you can return the pulled pork to the Crock Pot and set it on warm. This will keep it nice and warm for your guests.

Now you can assemble a sandwich. Add a large helping of pulled pork on the bottom bun. Then add some sliced pickles if desired, followed by the top half of the bun.

There you go, an awesome barbecue pulled pork sandwich. Enjoy!

How long does pulled pork last?

Keep leftovers in the bowl covered or in Tupperware in the fridge for up to 4 days. After that, you should freeze it in freezer bags.

Here are other recipes you may like:

Homemade Hamburger Buns

Homemade Barbecue Sauce

How to Make Rice Flour

Bacon Egg and Cheese Sandwich

Do you like this recipe? Share and Pin it! Please give it a rating and comment down below, I really appreciate it. If you make it tag me on Instagram @inthekitchenwithmatt. Also, sign up for the newsletter so you won’t miss out on any of my new posts and recipes.